Hilton Head Vs St Simons Island – A Comprehensive Guide

Sharing is caring!

Hilton Head and St. Simons Island are popular vacation destinations in the southeastern United States. Located along the coast, these islands offer beautiful beaches, stunning natural scenery, and a wide range of recreational activities.

Whether you’re looking for a relaxing beach getaway or an active outdoor adventure. Hilton Head and St. Simons Island have something to offer. We will take you on a virtual tour of both destinations. Exploring the differences between hilton head vs st simons island.

We will cover everything from the location, climate, and landscape to the history, culture, accommodation options, dining, nightlife, beaches, outdoor activities, shopping, entertainment, local events, festivals and transportation.

Hilton Head Vs St Simons Island

About Hilton Head Island

The second largest of the barrier islands that make up South Carolina. Hilton Head consists of four chain hotels of barrier islands. These are to be found at different points along the coast, and all have their characteristics.

Palmetto Acadia National Park stretches sand over a rough 3 km stretch between Captains Quarters Beach Road south to Long Bay; and Hilton Head Plantation Pines. Ocean Drive and Cumberland Island Gables end in front near Gap Creek.

Life on an island lifestyle affords many benefits, including a low cost of living as long as one’s income can cover vacation expenses. People know the island for its rich and stable cultural heritage, natural coastal environments, nearby beaches, low humidity, and the Pee Dee River estuary in Long Bay that sustains various sea life.

Hilton Head Hospital is the main hospital facility for Traveling To Hilton Head Vs. St. Simons Island. Providing medical services related to preventative and emergency care within a 35 minute-drivetime radius. Hilton Head’s population was estimated at 37 thousand by 2010.

About St Simons Island

An extensive housing market with luxury homes for less than $1 million abutting more modest neighbourhoods. Of single-family vacation houses for around $200,000. “St. Simons Island is a relatively large island with the third-highest residential property values in Georgia according to 2008 data on Realtor.com and 119th overall.”

The City of St Simons hosts its municipal government responsible for law enforcement, and public services (fire and EMS). Planning/zoning, road maintenance, etc. A wide range of luxury homes is clustered near Palmetto Bay, including 5-star golf resort residences atop coastal dunes by the oceanfront “Pointe” at high prices, both new or well-preserved Antebellum

um-style plantation homes. Most residential properties include manicured lawns, tennis courts, pool areas, and ocean views within the gated community of Windward Estates with a “sprawling clubhouse.”

Exploring The Differences: Hilton Head Vs St Simons Island

Exploring The Differences Hilton Head Vs St Simons Island

Hilton Head and St. Simons Island each offer their unique charm and appeal. Located in South Padre Island, Carolina, Hilton Head is larger and more populated than St. Simons Island in Georgia. Both destinations boast beautiful beaches, but Hilton Head leads with a wider range of beach activities and amenities.

Although St. Simons Island offers some options, golf enthusiasts will delight in Hilton Head’s numerous golf courses. Regarding dining and entertainment, Hilton Head takes the cake with various choices, including shopping centres and nightlife.

On the other hand, St. Simons Island shines with its natural beauty and wildlife. Providing opportunities for bird-watching and exploring nature lovers trails. Here we explore the difference between hilton head vs st simons island.

Location, Climate, And Landscape

Hilton Head and St. Simons Island are in South Carolina and Georgia, respectively. They both have a subtropical climate, although St. Simons Island experiences slightly cooler temperatures. Hilton Head is known for its beautiful beaches and flat terrain, perfect for biking and golfing.

On the other hand, St. Simons Island offers a mix of beaches, and marshes. And forests, providing opportunities for outdoor activities like fishing and birdwatching. Both destinations offer a variety of recreational activities, including golf courses, tennis courts, and water sports.

Hilton Head has a more developed tourism industry with numerous resorts, restaurants, and shopping options. In contrast, St. Simons Island has a more laid-back atmosphere, smaller-scale accommodations, and a charming downtown area.

History And Culture

Hilton Head Island and St. Simons Island have distinct histories and cultures. Hilton Head is renowned for its luxury resorts and golf courses, attracting visitors who seek a more upscale experience. On the other hand, St. Simons Island offers a relaxed and laid-back atmosphere.

Embodying the charm of a small coastal town. While Hilton Head boasts a larger population and a range of amenities and activities, St. Simons Island retains its historic character with local shops and eateries. Both islands offer stunning beaches and outdoor recreational opportunities, allowing visitors to appreciate the natural beauty of the Georgia coast.

Accommodations: Hotels, Resorts, And Vacation Rentals

Accommodations: Hotels, Resorts, And Vacation Rentals

Hilton Head and St. Simons Island offer various accommodations to suit different preferences. People know Hilton Head for its luxury resorts, upscale hotels, and vacation rentals. On the other hand, St. Simons Island has a more laid-back and relaxed atmosphere with various hotels.

Resorts and vacation rentals are available. Whether you prefer the upscale amenities and golf courses of Hilton Head or the charming and serene ambience of St. Simons Island. Both destinations provide ample options for a comfortable stay. From luxury resorts to cosy vacation rentals, visitors can find the perfect accommodation to suit their needs.

Dining And Nightlife

Regarding dining and nightlife, Hilton Head and St Simons Island offer unique experiences to their visitors. Hilton Head boasts diverse dining options, from upscale seafood restaurants to casual beachfront eateries. St. Simons Island’s charming local restaurants and seafood shacks are well-known.

Providing a more laid-back dining experience. In terms of nightlife, Hilton Head has a vibrant scene with bars, clubs, and live music venues. While St. Simons Island offers a more relaxed atmosphere with cosy pubs and beachside bars. Both destinations cater to different preferences, ensuring visitors have plenty of options for food and entertainment.

Beaches And Outdoor Activities

Hilton Head Island boasts pristine beaches and a wide range of outdoor activities, including golfing, biking, and water sports. On the other hand, St. Simons Island offers beautiful beaches and opportunities for fishing, boating, and kayaking. Hilton Head has more developed amenities, with a larger selection of resorts, restaurants, and shopping options.

In contrast, St Simons Island has a laid-back atmosphere, fewer crowds, and a slower pace. Both islands provide stunning natural beauty and chances for relaxation and exploration; choosing between them is a matter of personal preference and desired vacation experience.

Shopping And Entertainment

Regarding shopping and entertainment, Hilton Head and St. Simons Island offer distinct experiences. Hilton Head boasts a wide range of shopping options, from high-end boutiques to outlet malls, catering to all tastes. On the other hand, St. Simons Island’s shopping scene is more laid-back and quaint, with charming local shops and boutiques.

Regarding evening entertainment, Hilton Head has a vibrant nightlife with numerous bars, clubs, and live music venues, providing a lively and energetic atmosphere. In contrast, St. Simons Island offers a more relaxed and low-key evening entertainment, perfect for those seeking a peaceful coastal experience. Both destinations have beautiful beaches, each offering its unique charm and appeal.

Local Events And Festivals

Local Events And Festivals

Hilton Head Island boasts annual events like the Hilton Head Wine & Food Festival and the RBC Heritage Golf Tournament. On the other hand, St Simons Island hosts the St. Simons Island Food + Spirits Festival and the Golden Isles Live concert series. Both islands have diverse local events, including art festivals, music concerts, and holiday celebrations.

It’s essential to check the local event calendars when planning a visit, as the types of events and festivals may vary depending on the time of year. Whether you’re into wine tastings, live music, or cultural festivals, Hilton Head and St Simons Island offer plenty of options to suit different interests.

Transportation And Getting Around

Transportation and getting around these two coastal destinations are convenient for visitors. Hilton Head Island can be accessed by car via the Cross Island Parkway or by air through the Hilton Head Airport. Similarly, St.

Simons Island can be reached by car through the F.J. Torras Causeway or by air using the Brunswick Golden Isles Airport. Both islands have bike-friendly paths and rental options for those who prefer exploring on two wheels.

Hilton Head also offers a free trolley service during peak tourist seasons, providing an easy way to get around without a car. On the other hand, St. Simons Island does not have a public beach transportation system, so having a car or relying on ride-sharing services may be necessary to navigate the island.


Hilton Head’s cost is much more expensive than Simons Island regarding housing and rent, with an average price of $ 225,856. In addition, Hilton Head has higher prices for utilities like water parks ($3 per customer per month), while the same instalment is only $1 to use in Bullhead City.

Hilton Head also hosts a few hotter-than-average spots that are difficult on younger children if their parents want them to be within walking distance from houses, such as Gable House Tavern, located close by at 400 Savannah Hwy with a not-so-lucrative standard drink item at $8, which is comparable to Bullhead City’s spots with a far less pricey drinks item at only $5.

When Is The Best Time To Visit Saint Simons Or Hilton Head Island?

When Is The Best Time To Visit Saint Simons Or Hilton Head Island

The best time to visit Saint Simons Island or Hilton Head Island depends on what you’re looking for in your vacation. Both destinations offer beautiful beaches, warm weather, and a variety of outdoor activities year-round. However, if you prefer to avoid crowds and save money on accommodations, consider visiting during spring and fall shoulder seasons.

These times offer pleasant weather and fewer tourists compared to the peak summer months. On the other hand, if you’re seeking vibrant nightlife and a lively atmosphere, visiting during the summer when school is out may be more your speed. Ultimately, it’s important to consider your preferences and priorities when deciding the best time to visit these coastal getaways.

Typical Weather For Hilton Head Island And Saint Simons

Hilton Head Island and Saint Simons experience mild, subtropical climates, making them popular vacation destinations year-round. The typical weather for Hilton Head Island and Saint Simons includes warm summers with temperatures reaching the high 80s to low 90s Fahrenheit (30-35 degrees Celsius) and cooler winters with temperatures ranging from the mid-50s to low 60s Fahrenheit (10-15 degrees Celsius).

Both locations also see a fair amount of rainfall throughout the year, with the wettest months typically being June through August. It’s always a good idea to check the forecast before your trip. Still, generally, you can expect pleasant weather for outdoor activities and beach visits in Hilton Head Island and Saint Simons.

What Are The Benefits Of Visiting Hilton Head Vs St. Simons Island?

What Are The Benefits Of Visiting Hilton Head Vs St. Simons Island

When deciding between Hilton Head and St. Simons Island for your next vacation destination, it’s important to consider each location’s unique benefits. Hilton Head is known for its beautiful beaches, world-class golf courses, and luxurious resorts.

It’s a perfect destination for relaxing and indulging in upscale dining options and amenities. On the other hand, St. Simons Island offers a more laid-back and charming atmosphere, with its picturesque landscapes, historic sites, and quaint village area.

It’s an ideal choice for travelers seeking a slower pace and a chance to immerse themselves in the island’s rich history and natural beauty. Both destinations have their own distinct charm and attractions, so it ultimately comes down to personal preference and what type of vacation experience you’re looking for.

Which One Should I Go To?

Choosing between Hilton Head and St. Simons Island for your next vacation can be tough. Both destinations offer beautiful beaches, stunning scenery, and a Wide beaches range of activities for visitors to enjoy. Hilton Head is known for its world-class golf courses, luxurious resorts, and vibrant dining scene.

On the other hand, St. Simons Island offers a more laid-back atmosphere with its charming coastal villages, historic landmarks, and pristine natural beauty. Ultimately, the choice will depend on your personal preferences and what you want from your vacation. Whether you prefer the excitement and amenities of Hilton Head or the tranquil charm of St. Simons Island, you will surely have a memorable experience.


Both offer unique experiences and distinct charm. Hilton Head is known for its pristine beaches, world-class golf courses, and upscale resorts, making it a popular island destination for luxury travellers. On the other hand, St. Simons Island has a more laid-back vibe with its quaint downtown area, historic historical landmarks, and beautiful natural landscapes.

When deciding between the two islands, consider location, climate, accommodations, dining options, outdoor activities, shopping, and local events. Consider what you value most in a vacation and which island aligns better with your preferences.

Ultimately, the choice between Hilton Head Beach and St. Simons Island will depend on individual preferences and what kind of experience you are looking for. We hope now you understand the difference between hilton head vs st simons island.

Frequently Asked Questions

1.Is St Simons Island Worth Visiting?

Ans: Absolutely! St. Simons Island is definitely worth visiting. With its stunning beaches, charming atmosphere, and rich history, it offers something for everyone. St. Simons Island has it all, whether you’re interested in exploring the beautiful coastline, indulging in delicious seafood, or learning about the island’s fascinating past.

2.What Is So Special About Hilton Head Island?

Ans: Hilton Head Island is special because of its beautiful beaches, pristine natural environment, and abundant outdoor dining activities. The island offers a unique combination of tranquillity and adventure, with activities such as golfing, biking, kayaking, and fishing available to visitors. It is also known for its luxurious resorts, world-class dining options, and vibrant art galleries and culture scene.

3.Is It Worth Going To Hilton Head Island?

Ans: Absolutely! Hilton Head Island is worth a visit. Its stunning beaches, world-class golf courses, and many outdoor activities offer a vacation experience. Whether you’re looking to relax on the sand, tee off on a championship golf course, or explore the island’s natural beauty, Hilton Head Island has something for everyone.

4.Which Is Better, St Simons Island Or Tybee Island?

Ans: Deciding between St. Simons Island and Tybee Island depends on what you want in a coastal island getaway. St. Simons Island may be the perfect choice for a serene and quaint atmosphere focusing on history buffs and natural beauty. Its beautiful coastline, delicious seafood, and rich history make it a charming destination.

5.What Is The Prettiest Beach On St Simons?

Ans: St. Simons Island has several beautiful beaches, making choosing just one as the prettiest difficult. However, East Beach often tops the list for its expansive shoreline and stunning views. East Fernandina Beach is a true coastal paradise with soft white-sand beaches, gentle waves, and picturesque dunes.

Sharing is caring!

Leave a Comment

Sharing is Caring

Help spread the word. You're awesome for doing it!